The clip has been selected and now we are onto the challenge of how to best stage it. Staging seems to be an issue which plagues me, so I thought I would do two rough passes and get some feedback before I commit to the shot.
Here's the deal:
A wide shot which establishes more context and setting
Now, personally, it strikes me as odd to have dialogue in an establishing or wider shot. It seems like you would have the character enter and hit the elevator button, then cut in a little closer for the dialogue. Particularly, since this is not a monologue. With dialogue which is directed at another character a closer camera seems more conversational. In this case however, we have specific references to the setting in the dialogue. Does that merit or necessitate the inclusion of setting in the shot? Might I include a bell or passport on the desk to help stage the closer shot? Another interesting question- would that be too similar to the shot as it stands in the film I borrowed the clip from, and when/how/why/is that wrong? This is a tricky dilemma- sound off!
Here's the deal:
A wide shot which establishes more context and setting
OR
A closer shot which is more conversational and allowing for more subtlety of facial actingNow, personally, it strikes me as odd to have dialogue in an establishing or wider shot. It seems like you would have the character enter and hit the elevator button, then cut in a little closer for the dialogue. Particularly, since this is not a monologue. With dialogue which is directed at another character a closer camera seems more conversational. In this case however, we have specific references to the setting in the dialogue. Does that merit or necessitate the inclusion of setting in the shot? Might I include a bell or passport on the desk to help stage the closer shot? Another interesting question- would that be too similar to the shot as it stands in the film I borrowed the clip from, and when/how/why/is that wrong? This is a tricky dilemma- sound off!