Wednesday, May 21, 2008

Hands

Hand poses are super expressive. But also really tricky, as there is a lot to manage and finesse.

Below are two very similar hands. Which one do you prefer for the pose, and why?


3 comments:

Bobby Pontillas said...

Hey Maya,

I guess I would have to know the context of the scene to really make a call on which gesture is most appropriate.

But from the standpoint of what feels more natural, I'd have to say the first. Simply because the finger shapes seem to be working together better as a whole. Where as the second pic, the fingers are almost independent from each other and are a little more random and chaotic, especially the pinky.

Which again, may or may not be what you're going for, depending on the overall attitude.

Then again I could be talking completely out of my ass.

TheZealot said...

I'm going to say the same. I'll say this: the second hand has an intensity to it that the first doesn't. When Indiana Jones has drunk the mind-control potion in "Doom", his hands do this. What makes it work is the angle of the finger bottom to the palm.
To me the 1st hand isn't intense enough or relaxed enough; it's in the middle, like the hand is just about to grab a large ball.

TheZealot said...

P.S. How are you?